Experimental commits that should be combined
Tests ability to identify experimental commits that should be combined into a single coherent change. Evaluates recognizing exploratory work patterns.
Baseline Repository
These commands set up the repo before the model sees the prompt. They define the starting file structure, staged changes, and Git history.
- 01
git init - 02
git config user.email 'test@test.com' - 03
git config user.name 'Test User' - 04
echo 'base' > base.txt - 05
git add base.txt - 06
git commit -m 'Base setup' - 07
echo 'exp1' > experiment.py - 08
git add experiment.py - 09
git commit -m 'Experiment v1' - 10
echo 'exp2' > experiment.py - 11
git add experiment.py - 12
git commit -m 'Experiment v2' - 13
echo 'final' > experiment.py - 14
git add experiment.py - 15
git commit -m 'Experiment final'
Prompt
Find the intermediate commits that should be marked as squash/fixup to clean up experimental work. These are consecutive commits with similar purpose that were split during development. Do not include the final experiment commit as one of the commits to squash. Provide the commit messages.
Expected
Experiment v1, Experiment v2
Campaign Evidence
Loading campaign evidence…
Model Outputs (14)
Based on the instruction, you want to find consecutive commits with a similar purpose that were split during development. Here, the three experiments ("Experiment v1", "Experiment v2", and "Experiment final") are clearly part of the same development sequence.
Since "final" should be kept, the intermediate commits to squash/fixup are:
- **52a9303 Experiment v2**
- **8a94060 Experiment v1**
Failure: Extra selected commit messages: ['Experiment final']
4a588f1 Experiment v2
888baaa Experiment v1
JSON Schema
Structured Output
(raw) {"commits":["4a588f1 Experiment v2","888baaa Experiment v1"]}
Based on the commit history provided, the intermediate commits that should be marked as `squash` or `fixup` to clean up the experimental work are:
1. `51339ae Experiment v2`
2. `b6624a9 Experiment v1`
These are consecutive commits with similar purposes (experimental work) that were split during development. The final commit `a94afba Experiment final` should not be squashed as it represents the final state of the experiment.
The commit messages to mark for squashing would be:
- `51339ae Experiment v2`
- `b6624a9 Experiment v1`
You would typically use `git rebase -i` to mark these commits with `squash` or `fixup` (depending on whether you want to keep their messages or not) to combine them into the final experiment commit.
08f63df
a9467e8
JSON Schema
Structured Output
(raw) {"commits": ["08f63df", "a9467e8"]}
The experimental commits that should be squashed/fix‑ups (and therefore are the ones you’ll reference when you run `git rebase -i` or `git commit --squash`) are:
- **Experiment v2** (commit 2669e4a)
- **Experiment v1** (commit 00934e3)
These are the intermediate commits that chain up to the final “Experiment final” commit; the final experiment commit itself (42da903 “Experiment final”) is intentionally left out, as instructed.
Failure: Extra selected commit messages: ['Experiment final']
Experiment v2
Experiment v1
JSON Schema
Structured Output
(raw) {
"commits": [
"Experiment v2",
"Experiment v1"
]
}
To clean up the experimental work by squashing the intermediate commits **while excluding the final "Experiment final" commit**, we identify the range of commits formed by the experimental work.
---
### **Identification of Commits to Squash**
The experimental commits are:
- **260ea1f Experiment v1** (earliest experimental commit)
- **b61d7a6 Experiment v2**
- **ae831e3 Experiment final** (final experiment commit — **not to be squashed**, as per the instruction)
These three commits are **consecutive** and share the common prefix `Experiment`. The goal is to combine these **three** commits into **one**, preserving only the final `Experiment final` commit as a **standalone commit**, and squashing the preceding two (`Experiment v1` and `Experiment v2`) into it.
---
### **Key Clarification**
- The final commit (`ae831e3 Experiment final`) is the **target of the squash**, not part of the commits to squash.
- Therefore, the **commits to squash** are:
1. `260ea1f Experiment v1`
2. `b61d7a6 Experiment v2`
> These are the **intermediate commits** that were split during development and should be squashed to clean up the experimental work.
---
### **Commit Messages to Squash**
The commit messages that should be marked as **squash/fixup** are:
- `Experiment v1`
- `Experiment v2`
These are the **only intermediate commits** that need to be squashed. The final `Experiment final` commit is preserved as the consolidated result.
---
### ✅ Final Answer:
**Commit messages to squash:**
- `Experiment v1`
- `Experiment v2`
Failure: Extra selected commit messages: ['Experiment final']
Experiment v2
Experiment v1
JSON Schema
Structured Output
(raw) {
"commits": [
"Experiment v2",
"Experiment v1"
]
}
Based on the commit history, I can see the experimental work consists of three commits that were split during development:
**Commits to squash/fixup:**
1. `e641c6b` - **Experiment v1**
2. `4b2263a` - **Experiment v2**
These two intermediate commits should be marked as squash/fixup since they represent the split development work that should be combined into the final `Experiment final` commit. The `Experiment final` commit should absorb these changes, and `Base setup` remains as the independent starting point.
Failure: Extra selected commit messages: ['Experiment final', 'Base setup']
Experiment v2
Experiment v1
JSON Schema
Structured Output
(raw) {"commits": ["Experiment v2", "Experiment v1"]}
Looking at the commit history, I can see a series of experimental commits that appear to be part of the same development work:
**Commits to squash/fixup:**
- `Experiment v1` (98292f7)
- `Experiment v2` (b4b7848)
These two commits should be marked as squash/fixup since they represent intermediate steps of the same experimental work. The `Experiment final` commit (7d9f24a) should remain as the final, clean result and should not be included in the squash operations.
The `Base setup` commit (69e974a) appears to be the foundation and should remain separate.
Failure: Extra selected commit messages: ['Experiment final']
19a8bae Experiment v2
ed362a4 Experiment v1
JSON Schema
Structured Output
(raw) {"commits": ["19a8bae Experiment v2", "ed362a4 Experiment v1"]}
Experimentv1, Experiment v2
Failure: Missing expected commit messages: ['Experiment v1']
Invalid JSON. Output: The intermediate commits that should be marked as squash or fixup are:
- Experiment v2
- Experiment v1
These are the consecutive experimental commits that were split during development and should be combined into the final experiment commit (526cfdc Experiment final), which is excluded from squashing.
JSON Schema
Structured Output
Structured Output Error
Failed to parse structured JSON response: Expecting value: line 1 column 1 (char 0)
Failure: Failed to parse structured JSON response: Expecting value: line 1 column 1 (char 0)