Documentation then fixup pattern
Tests ability to squash documentation-only fixup commits into the implementation commit. Evaluates recognizing doc-then-fixup patterns.
Baseline Repository
These commands set up the repo before the model sees the prompt. They define the starting file structure, staged changes, and Git history.
- 01
git init - 02
git config user.email 'test@test.com' - 03
git config user.name 'Test User' - 04
echo 'content' > main.md - 05
git add main.md - 06
git commit -m 'Add documentation' - 07
echo 'content more' > main.md - 08
git add main.md - 09
git commit -m 'WIP: update docs' - 10
echo 'content more done' > main.md - 11
git add main.md - 12
git commit -m 'WIP: finalize docs'
Prompt
Identify the commits that represent incremental work-in-progress updates to documentation and should be marked as squash/fixup. Do not include the documentation anchor commit they would be squashed into. Provide the commit messages.
Expected
WIP: update docs, WIP: finalize docs
Campaign Evidence
Loading campaign evidence…
Model Outputs (14)
The commits that represent incremental work-in-progress updates to documentation are:
- `WIP: finalize docs`
- `WIP: update docs`
WIP: finalize docs
WIP: update docs
JSON Schema
Structured Output
(raw) {"commits":["WIP: finalize docs","WIP: update docs"]}
Based on the commit history, the commits that represent incremental work-in-progress updates to documentation are:
- 99501bf WIP: finalize docs
- 7f127a3 WIP: update docs
These two commits are clearly WIP (work-in-progress) commits that build upon the initial documentation commit. They should be marked for squash/fixup into the documentation anchor commit (7cbc965 Add documentation). The anchor commit itself is not included in the list, as requested.
Failure: Extra selected commit messages: ['Add documentation']
d460bfc WIP: finalize docs
3f624e3 WIP: update docs
JSON Schema
Structured Output
(raw) {"commits":["d460bfc WIP: finalize docs","3f624e3 WIP: update docs"]}
Based on the commit history provided, the commits that represent incremental work-in-progress updates to documentation and should be marked as squash/fixup are:
1. `71b4f7f WIP: finalize docs`
2. `c5f7e56 WIP: update docs`
These commits appear to be incremental updates to the documentation that would be squashed into the anchor commit `dfbc583 Add documentation`.
WIP: finalize docs
WIP: update docs
JSON Schema
Structured Output
(raw) {"commits": ["WIP: finalize docs", "WIP: update docs"]}
Based on the typical pattern of "WIP" (Work In Progress) commits for documentation updates – where these are iterative, non-final changes that will later be squashed with a dedicated "documentation anchor" commit (e.g., "finalize docs") – the commits to mark as squash/fixup are the WIP commits *before* the final anchor commit.
Here's the analysis of the commit history (newest first):
- **6caba87**: "WIP: finalize docs" → This is *not* incremental (it's labeled "finalize", implying it's the target anchor commit).
- **a149d7b**: "WIP: update docs" → **Incremental WIP documentation commit** (should be squash/fixup).
- **4c94232**: "Add documentation" → `Add` is a *base commit*, not a WIP incremental update (it's the initial documentation addition).
**Commits to mark as squash/fixup**:
Only commits with "WIP" in the message that are *not* the anchor commit.
- `a149d7b WIP: update docs` qualifies.
- `4c94232 "Add documentation"` does **not** (it's a standalone base commit).
**Commit message to provide**:
`a149d7b WIP: update docs`
### Why?
- This is the *only* commit containing "WIP" in its message and represents an incremental documentation update (not the final anchor).
- It must be squash/fixup'd to clean up the history before the anchor commit (`6caba87: WIP: finalize docs`).
- The anchor commit itself (`6caba87`) and the base commit (`4c94232`) are excluded per the instructions.
**Answer**:
`a149d7b WIP: update docs`
Failure: Extra selected commit messages: ['Add documentation']
WIP: update docs
WIP: finalize docs
JSON Schema
Structured Output
(raw) {
"commits": [
"WIP: update docs",
"WIP: finalize docs"
]
}
Based on the commit history, the following commits represent incremental work-in-progress updates to documentation that should be marked as squash/fixup:
- `32b409f WIP: finalize docs`
- `b62db79 WIP: update docs`
These WIP commits would be squashed into the main documentation anchor commit `96597ad Add documentation`.
WIP: finalize docs
WIP: update docs
JSON Schema
Structured Output
(raw) {"commits": ["WIP: finalize docs", "WIP: update docs"]}
Based on the commit history provided, here are the commits that represent incremental work-in-progress updates to documentation and should be marked as squash/fixup:
1. `dfcce7e` - WIP: finalize docs
2. `1eb4d1b` - WIP: update docs
These two commits show clear work-in-progress patterns with "WIP" prefixes and sequential documentation update messages. They would be squashed into or fixup'd to the documentation anchor commit `4d5ec38` "Add documentation".
WIP: finalize docs
WIP: update docs
JSON Schema
Structured Output
(raw) {"commits": ["WIP: finalize docs", "WIP: update docs"]}
Add documentation
WIP: update docs
JSON Schema
Structured Output
(raw) { "commits": [ "Add documentation", "WIP: update docs" ] }
Failure: Missing expected commit messages: ['WIP: finalize docs']
(empty output)
Failure: Missing expected commit messages: ['WIP: update docs', 'WIP: finalize docs']