Test commits first then implementation
Tests ability to squash test-first commits with their implementation commits. Evaluates recognizing TDD-style commit patterns.
Baseline Repository
These commands set up the repo before the model sees the prompt. They define the starting file structure, staged changes, and Git history.
- 01
git init - 02
git config user.email 'test@test.com' - 03
git config user.name 'Test User' - 04
echo 'code' > app.py - 05
git add app.py - 06
git commit -m 'Initial app' - 07
echo 'import unittest' > test.py - 08
git add test.py - 09
git commit -m 'WIP: add test stub' - 10
echo 'import unittest class Test(unittest.TestCase): pass' > test.py - 11
git add test.py - 12
git commit -m 'WIP: expand test' - 13
echo 'import unittest class Test(unittest.TestCase): def test_ok(self): pass' > test.py - 14
git add test.py - 15
git commit -m 'Complete tests'
Prompt
Identify the WIP commits that should be marked as squash/fixup for a cleaner test file addition. Do not include the final complete-tests commit. Provide the commit messages.
Expected
WIP: add test stub, WIP: expand test
Campaign Evidence
Loading campaign evidence…
Model Outputs (14)
- WIP: expand test
- WIP: add test stub
71f5304 WIP: add test stub
895c158 WIP: expand test
JSON Schema
Structured Output
(raw) { "commits": [ "71f5304 WIP: add test stub", "895c158 WIP: expand test" ] }
Based on the commit history, the WIP commits that should be marked as squash/fixup for a cleaner test file addition are:
- `60d77e4 WIP: expand test`
- `3cdb613 WIP: add test stub`
These two commits build incrementally toward the final test file, and they should be squashed together (keeping the message of one or creating a new combined message) before reaching the `7eeb0bf Complete tests` commit.
Failure: Extra selected commit messages: ['Complete tests']
d333d00 WIP: add test stub
0491ff8 WIP: expand test
JSON Schema
Structured Output
(raw) {"commits": ["d333d00 WIP: add test stub", "0491ff8 WIP: expand test"]}
Based on the commit history, the WIP commits that should be marked as squash/fixup for a cleaner test file addition are:
1. `b3d6cad WIP: expand test` (should be squashed/fixup into the final commit)
2. `e799a10 WIP: add test stub` (should be squashed/fixup into the final commit)
These are intermediate work-in-progress commits that would be better consolidated into the final "Complete tests" commit for a cleaner history. The commit messages to mark would be:
```
b3d6cad WIP: expand test
e799a10 WIP: add test stub
```
WIP: expand test
WIP: add test stub
JSON Schema
Structured Output
(raw) {
"commits": [
"WIP: expand test",
"WIP: add test stub"
]
}
- **WIP: expand test**
- **WIP: add test stub**
WIP: expand test
WIP: add test stub
JSON Schema
Structured Output
(raw) {
"commits": [
"WIP: expand test",
"WIP: add test stub"
]
}
Based on the provided Git commit history and the requirement to identify **WIP commits for squash/fixup** (excluding `Complete tests`), the relevant WIP commits are:
```
WIP: add test stub
WIP: expand test
```
### Why these commits?
- **`2954762 Initial app`** is the **base commit** (final complete commit), so it is **excluded** per your instructions.
- **`594fd6c WIP: expand test`** and **`2b99a81 WIP: add test stub`** are the **partial WIP commits** that should be squashed/fixed up to clean up the test file addition.
- The final commit (`9221f34 Complete tests`) is already resolved and **should not be included** in the squash/fixup process.
### Target for squashing:
You should squash **both** WIP commits (`WIP: add test stub` and `WIP: expand test`) into a single commit (e.g., using `git rebase -i HEAD~3`), **excluding** `Complete tests`.
### Commit messages to provide (as requested):
```
WIP: add test stub
WIP: expand test
```
Failure: Extra selected commit messages: ['Complete tests', 'Initial app']
WIP: add test stub
WIP: expand test
JSON Schema
Structured Output
(raw) {
"commits": [
"WIP: add test stub",
"WIP: expand test"
]
}
Based on the commit history, here are the WIP commits that should be marked as squash/fixup for a cleaner test file addition:
1. **WIP: expand test** (640917f)
2. **WIP: add test stub** (f19d399)
These two commits represent the incremental work that was ultimately completed in the final "Complete tests" commit. Squashing or marking them as fixup would create a cleaner project history by consolidating the work-in-progress changes into the final complete commit.
WIP: expand test
WIP: add test stub
JSON Schema
Structured Output
(raw) {"commits": ["WIP: expand test", "WIP: add test stub"]}
I'll identify the WIP commits that should be squashed or marked as fixup for a cleaner test file addition.
Based on the commit history, the WIP commits that should be marked as squash/fixup are:
1. "WIP: expand test"
2. "WIP: add test stub"
These two commits represent work-in-progress changes that build upon each other and should be combined with the final "Complete tests" commit for a cleaner history. The "Initial app" commit is the starting point and should remain separate.
WIP: expand test
WIP: add test stub
JSON Schema
Structured Output
(raw) {"commits": ["WIP: expand test", "WIP: add test stub"]}